The Supreme Court conditionally granted mandamus and directed the district court to render judgment on an 11–1 defense verdict. The Court concluded that the new-trial order misunderstood the law governing medical negligence.
The Court also criticized a dissenting juror’s letter describing deliberations that had accompanied the new-trial motion. The dispute involved the patient’s chance of avoiding amputation following an initial bandsaw injury.
Sources & further reading
Prepared Nov 13, 2026. This is a selective summary of the linked materials. Later filings and rulings may affect status. Practice notes are editorial observations, not holdings of the court.